Children’s Commissioner warns Scottish Government over proposed data centre guidance


“Impact assessment and children’s views needed”

The Children’s Commissioner has warned the Scottish Government that its development of data centre guidance risks not complying with its legal duties to children.  

Writing to the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad MSP, Commissioner Nicola Killean states that the potential environmental impacts posed by data centres clearly interacts with children’s rights as set out in law.  

In her letter, the Commissioner calls on the Scottish Government to do an impact assessment, and a consultation with children and young people to inform the development of the data centre guidance.  

Under the UNCRC (Scotland) Act 2004, Ministers are required to prepare and publish a Children’s Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment (CRWIA) for decisions of a strategic nature relating to children’s rights and wellbeing.  

Commissioner Killean said in the letter it was her view that “the preparation and publication of data centres guidance is a clear example of a strategic nature. It is not an operational or routine matter and therefore a CRWIA must be undertaken.” 

She further suggested that individual applications should have a CRWIA completed where the Scottish Government is the decision-maker, citing the proposed development in Redheughs, Edinburgh, as an example.  

The Commissioner also questioned the exclusion of children and young people’s views on data centres due to the government’s decision not to do a public consultation on the issue.   

Raising the concern that this approach does not meet the Scottish Government’s human rights obligations to include the views of children and young people in decision-making, she further points out that it does not reflect the Scottish Government’s own  Public Engagement Strategy for Climate and Nature.  

Ms Killean has asked the Scottish Government to: 

  • Confirm that a Child Rights and Wellbeing Assessment will be carried out in relation to the guidance, and on applications where the Scottish Government is a decision-maker  
  • Set out what the Scottish Government is doing to ensure the meaningful participation of children and young people as part of the development of the data centre guidance. 

The Commissioner has submitted evidence to the joint Parliamentary call for evidence, from the Climate Action Committee and the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee, on hyperscale data centres.

Data Centres – Letter from the Commissioner to the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad MSP

Back to top