Response to the Joint Call for Evidence from the Climate Action Committee and the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee on Hyperscale Data Centres.

Response to the Joint Call for Evidence from the Climate Action Committee and the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee on Hyperscale Data Centres.

November 2026

Established by the Commissioner for Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2003, the Commissioner is responsible for promoting and safeguarding the rights of all children and young people in Scotland, giving particular attention to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). The Commissioner has powers to review law, policy and practice and to take action to promote and protect rights. The Commissioner is fully independent of the Scottish Government.

The Climate Action Committee would like to understand:

  1. What are the potential environmental impacts of the construction and operation of hyperscale data centres and opportunities to deliver environmental benefits including: 
  1. water quality and consumption 
  2. air quality 
  3. nature and biodiversity, including soil quality 
  4. noise pollution 
  5. energy use and reuse, and associated generation (including of back up generation) 
  6. emissions, and where emissions could be avoided by, for example, using waste heat  
  7. temperature changes around hyperscale data centres 

Data centre development in Scotland should be seen as a children’s rights issue, and we are pleased to take this opportunity to share our views with the Committee. There is a clear interaction between children’s rights under the UNCRC and the potential environmental impacts posed by the development of data centres.

Children and young people have continuously raised their concerns to us about the current and future effects of climate change in Scotland and around the world. They have voiced to us how important it is that steps are taken to tackle the combined nature and climate crisis’s we face.

‘Climate change is really important. It’s pointless working on everything ese if the planet is not going to be liveable’ (Child, CYPCS Strategic Plan consultation response)

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child highlighted the importance of these issues in its recent General Comment No. 26 (2023) which focused on children’s rights and the environment;

‘The extent and magnitude of the triple planetary crisis, comprising the climate emergency, the collapse of biodiversity and pervasive pollution, is an urgent and systemic threat to children’s rights globally’

The most recent Concluding Observations made by the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child with regard to the UK highlighted the need to;

‘Ensure that national policies and programmes on addressing environmental protection, climate change and disaster risk management… are developed and implemented in accordance with the principles of the Convention and take into account children’s needs and views.’

At a domestic level, in Scotland we note the extent to which local community groups, environmental organisations and experts have all spoken about their concerns regarding the potential environmental impacts of data centres[1].

The Commissioner is aware of the following concerns:

  • High levels of energy consumption compared to availability, the impact on prices and energy costs at a time when so many families are struggling with the cost of living and there are still unacceptably high levels of child poverty in Scotland.[2]
  • the extent to which energy would need to be provided by fossil fuels, either directly or when backup generators are used-with the environmental impacts associated with them both locally and in terms of carbon emissions.[3]
  • the amount of water that data centres require and the impact this could have, especially in rising summer temperatures and heatwaves[4].
  • the impact of noise and light pollution on children’s health and quality of life.[5]
  • The impact on local development and particularly housing.

In the context of a housing emergency declared by both the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government, there must be recognition of the cross-cutting nature of this issue and an approach to decision-making that identifies and balances competing legal and policy considerations.

These issues clearly engage a range of children’s rights under the UNCRC, and consequent obligations on government including but not limited to Articles 2, 3, 4, 12, 27, 31.

Furthermore, taken together, these matters must raise questions over the Scottish Government’s ability to deliver on its statutory climate change targets as set out in the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009. There is a clear need for any guidance and decision-making on data centre development to take account of the requirement to comply with this legislation. We encourage the Committee to take account of this in its work and particularly its engagement with Scottish Government.

  • What systems are, or should be, in place to support avoidance or mitigation of negative environmental impacts?

We would urge the Committee to apply a child’s rights-based approach to its work and to any recommendations made to the Scottish Government.

Climate change and biodiversity loss are important child’s rights issues, impacting on protected rights under the United Nation’s Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC).  The most obvious and necessary mitigation therefore is to ensure that children’s rights are recognised and taken full account of.

A full and detailed child’s rights impact assessment (CRIA) should be carried out at early stages of key decisions relating to data centres. to identify interactions with children’s rights under the UNCRC. Where there is potential for a negative impact on rights mitigations should put in place and outlined in the CRIA.

A CRIA is an evaluation of the likely impacts of a legislative provision on, or decision of a strategic nature relating to, the rights and wellbeing of children prepared under section 17(1) of the UNCRC (Scotland) Act 2024

The Scottish Government has undertaken to produce national, strategic guidance which will provide an oversight for the operation of data centres and planning processes in Scotland. It is important that best practice is followed and that rights interactions and potential violations are properly explored at the outset and every stage of implementation, particularly regarding the impacts on children from an environmental viewpoint and the effect of rising energy prices on child poverty.

The Children’s Scheme published under s14 of the UNCRC (Scotland) Act 2024 provides that Ministers are required to prepare and publish a CRWIA for decisions of a strategic nature relating to children’s rights and wellbeing. These are described as ‘key, high-level decisions that Scottish Ministers take which may impact on the Scottish Government’s ability to respect, protect and fulfil children’s rights. Strategic decisions would normally include high-level decisions about: setting policy priorities; allocating resources; and policy delivery and implementation but would not normally include decisions which are operational or routine (such as, for example, many taken in the planning, consenting and licensing sectors).”

It is the Commissioner’s view that the preparation and publication of data centres guidance is a clear example of a decision of a strategic nature. It is not an operational or routine matter and therefore a CRIA must be undertaken.

We note that in her address to the Parliament, Hannah Goodlad MSP – The Minister for Public Finance spoke about the ‘potential impact of large-scale data centres; and announced that national guidance was to be issued before any applications were granted –  ‘to take a national perspective on the issue’ –‘ to have strategic oversight of the issue’. She further highlighted[6];

‘I assure the Parliament that the Government absolutely recognises the need for careful scrutiny of planning applications and of their likely impacts on the environment and our communities. We recognise that people expect decisions to be taken transparently and on the basis of robust evidence. It is essential that the public and the Government have confidence in the process.’

We submit that there should not only be a CRIA on the overall guidance but on individual applications where the Scottish Ministers are the decision maker – such as the application at Redheughs, Edinburgh. Ministers have been clear these decisions are being called in in order for strategic oversight to be in place, recognising the collective and cumulative, as well as individual, impacts of large data centre developments.  

Children’s Participation –

‘At this point what can we do – the governments are not doing what they need to’(Child, CYPCS Strategic Plan consultation response)

We are disappointed to learn that the Scottish Government does not intend to carry out a public consultation to inform the content of the data centre guidance instead relying on a targeted consultation with key stakeholders. We are concerned that this guidance will not properly or meaningfully reflect the Government’s obligations to include the voices and views of children and young people in decision making[7].

Children and young people should be properly involved in decision making processes surrounding these issues. This should be meaningful, effective and not tokenistic. Children and young people are clear that it is their future environment and want to be involved in protecting it.

The United Nations Special Rapporteur on the environment has commented that children are more at risk from environmental problems than adults, but their views and interests are often left out of decisions.[8]

Indeed, the Scottish Government has recognised the importance of this itself. There is an obligation imposed on Ministers by section 91 of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 to create a Public Engagement Strategy (“PES”) and update it every five years. Ministers have recently prepared a new strategy to cover the years 2026 to 2031. In September 2026, Ministers published their CRWIA in respect of the strategy[9].

The new Strategy, also published in September 2026, states at page 29:-

“Children and young people (CYP) will be disproportionately affected by the impacts of climate change and nature loss throughout their lifetimes. […]. [C]hildren want to learn more about climate change, and the action being taken, as well as to have meaningful opportunities to influence decision-making. Engagement must respect the rights of CYP and actively work to support climate literacy, critical thinking and participation, while enabling them to take action and have a voice in their communities. CYP bring creative ideas to climate engagement and their involvement in intergenerational and community engagement can add significant value to climate action delivery.”

At page 44, the document adds:-

“Net Zero Nation has highlighted the importance for young people to have access to climate education and a genuine role in decision making on climate change.”

The document also mentions on page 6 that the new strategy will support the Scottish Government’s core strategy “National Just Transition Planning Framework” (2021), which itself states at page 34: “Youth voices are particularly important in this process given our intergenerational responsibility to deliver the best possible future for our young people; their voices must therefore be central to creating that net zero future.” The CRWIA for the new strategy cites a series of Articles from the UNCRC and supports the need for children to participate in discussions and have their voices heard.

As such, we submit that the Government is failing by its own standards to consider the views of children and young people on a matter which significantly impacts on their rights.

We spoke to the Commissioner’s Young Advisors about what meaningful and effective participation should look like. They told us that the ways in which consultations were done were a real barrier to them. Little effort is made to make materials available in child friendly formats. Even if child friendly documents are available, these are not going to be appropriate for all children and young people.

‘It works great if it’s easily accessible to all children and young people.’ (CYPCS Young Advisor).

They also wanted to share that being asked about an idea once and then never hearing from decision makers again was not acceptable. They want decision makers to be accountable to them and return to tell them how their input has been used and in what ways it has been effective.

We hope the Committee will consider how it hears from children and young people who are affected and engaged on these issues as it progresses work in this area.

  • What can Scotland learn from other countries on the environmental impacts of hyperscale data centres? 
  1. How building and running hyperscale data centres in Scotland might impact on achieving climate and nature goals? 

Scotland has clearly stated commitments to tackling the combined climate and nature emergencies.

There is real concern that without proper regulation, the expansion of data centres in Scotland, could hinder the ability of the Government to deliver on these goals and thus not fulfil their duties to children’s rights.

  1. What criteria should a hyperscale data centre meet in order to be considered “green”? 

The Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee would like to understand:

  1. What are the potential impacts of data centre development on Scotland’s economy, including:
    • jobs 
    • investment
    • supply chains
    • tax revenues
    • attracting business to locate in Scotland
    • the extent to which any economic benefits can be retained in Scotland?

Care should be taken to properly assess the potential impact of data centre development on the economy and compare this to the environmental impact. It may be that there are only predominantly short-term gains to be made for the economy from such investment. The longer-term cost by damage to the climate or to Scotland’s biodiversity may far outweigh any short-term gain. It is widely reported that the ability of these developments to produce jobs is limited in the long-term – with the majority of jobs in the construction and building phase.

The Scottish Government has undertaken to address the housing emergency by building a significant number of houses to address the severe lack of affordable and social housing in this country. We are concerned that focusing investment and construction workforce on data centres could impact on the capacity and resource to meet these housing needs of the country. Care should be taken to ensure that this impact is carefully considered.

There is also the wider impact of the expansion of AI use in Scotland, something which these data centres are designed to support. We are concerned about the future of young people entering the job market and the impact AI is having on the impact on the opportunities available for young people.

  1. What impacts could increased data centre development have on Scotland’s energy system, including: 
    • electricity demand
    • electricity generation
    • network infrastructure
    • utilisation of waste heat
    • utitlisation of curtailed renewable electricity
    • overall network balancing?
  2. What actions should be taken to ensure that the economic and energy implications of data centre development in Scotland are appropriately assessed, planned for and managed at a pace that reflects the rapid growth of AI and demand for digital infrastructure?

As outlined above, a full CRIA should be carried out to properly assess the potential impact on the rights of children and young people under the UNCRC.

If you require any further information regarding this submission, then please contact Kit.Thompson@cypcs.org.uk


[1] APRS Hyperscale Data Centres Campaign – Action to Protect Rural Scotland

[2] Hyperscale data centres could see bills soaring – Scottish Greens

[3] Why the rush to build enormous power-guzzling data centres could screw up Scotland’s energy ambitions, damage the environment and leave people in the dark – Stop Climate Chaos Scotland

[4] Scottish data centres powering AI already using enough water to fill 27 million bottles a year – BBC News

[5] Your Guide to AI Data Centres in Scotland | Scottish Civic Trust

[6] OfficialReport

[7] Scottish Government failing on data centre guidance – Scottish Greens

[8] Children’s rights and the environment | OHCHR       

[9] Our Scotland, Our Future: Public Engagement Strategy for Climate and Nature – EQIA – gov.scot

Back to top