Evidence to UK Parliament House of Lords Communications and Digital Select Committee Inquiry: The Online Safety Act: Implementation and Impact

Evidence to UK Parliament House of Lords Communications and Digital Select Committee Inquiry: The Online Safety Act: Implementation and Impact

Our response to the Communications and Digital Select Committee inquiry on the Online Safety Act was published on 19 November 2026, and is available to download on the Committee’s website here.

 

Question 13: How well can the existing online safety framework respond to emerging harms and technologies? What changes, within the existing framework of the Act, are needed to ensure that it remains fit for the future, and should these be made within the existing framework or through further primary legislation? 

  1. As we note in our response to the Question 14, in our view the most important change in regulatory approach to address emerging harms is a focus on safety by design. The Model Code of Practice on Safety by Design1 co-produced by organisations working on online safety and children’s rights provides a helpful framework. It focuses on assessment of risk at a much earlier stage, and prioritising compliance with human rights and transparency. This is likely to be one of the most effective ways to protect children from harm while supporting their human rights. 
  1. The UK Government and Ofcom must also ensure regulation operates at a pace that is able to address issues as they arise, in particular given the rising role of AI in young people’s online experiences and the often limited regulation of this. 

Question 14: What impact could the recent and proposed additions to the UK’s online safety framework, including the Government’s proposals to restrict access to social media for under 16s, have on the OSA’s implementation and effectiveness? 

  1. The Commissioner conducted a Child Rights Impact Assessment (CRIA) in response to the Government’s proposal to ban under 16s from using social media.2 This highlighted the children’s rights impacts of the proposal and drew from input provided by our Young Advisors group. 
  1. We raised significant concern that the ban is likely to restrict children and young people’s access to information and right to free expression, while failing to prevent them being exposed to online harms on social media. A ban is likely to reduce pressure on companies to ensure their platforms are safe for young people by design and that safety measures are implemented. It is also likely that young people will still find ways to access social media platforms or be pushed towards less regulated parts of the internet, leaving them at greater risk of being exposed to unsafe online environments.  
  1. Evidence from LSE’s Digital Futures for Children research centre has shown that significant online risks to children remain, despite measures implemented under the Online Safety Act (OSA).3 It includes findings that while age assurance measures are now implemented across a range of platforms, there remains a lack of transparency around these systems which vary widely across platforms. 
  1. The UK Government’s own research on young people’s circumvention of age restrictions shows nearly two in five had successfully bypassed age checks, including more advanced age verification.4 It also found young people often seek out platforms without age verification. Young people’s concerns about privacy are highlighted by high usage of VPNs which can also enable bypassing of age verification. 
  1. These findings back up our concerns that a ban for under 16s will simply further undermine children’s safety online. Given that OSA measures have not yet succeeded in protecting children from online harms, diverting efforts towards a ban is likely to reduce pressure on companies to provide services which are safe for young people, and shift the focus away from safety by design. When children aren’t ‘supposed’ to be on social media, companies are unlikely to prioritise their safety on the platform. A focus on preventing access also does nothing to address the use of harmful addictive algorithms which young people will still be exposed to when they reach 16. 
  1. In its response to the consultation, the Government made the welcome decision not to restrict VPN usage which is vital to children and adults’ privacy online. However, its commitments to push companies to improve age assurance are without evidence of how this can be done well, and certainly that it can be done without significant interference with privacy rights of children and adults. Equally, setting default protections from infinite scroll and personalised algorithms for 16-17 year olds may temporarily protect them from some harms, but they are easily turned off and leave the burden with the user. 
  1. In our view, the focus on a ban and halfway measures for young people over 16 undermines efforts to address online harms through the OSA, and distracts from the real problem which is companies prioritising profit over harm. Focusing efforts instead on effective regulation for safety by design, addressing harms from a preventive standpoint and therefore enabling regulation to better keep pace with emerging harms is what is needed to enable children to exercise their rights safely online. 

Back to top