Data Centres – Letter from the Commissioner to the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad MSP

Data Centres – Letter from the Commissioner to the Minister for Public Finance, Hannah Mary Goodlad MSP

Hannah Mary Goodlad MSP, Minister for Public Finance

Cc. Gillian Martin MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs

Via email: MinisterforPF@gov.scot, CabSecforCARA@gov.scot

12 November 2026

Dear Minister,

I understand that the Scottish Government is currently developing guidance relating to the strategic oversight of data centre development in Scotland. I welcome this work, however I am concerned that children’s rights may not be fully taken account of in its development.

There is a clear interaction between children’s rights under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) and the potential environmental impacts posed by the development of data centres. I set out these matters in more detail in my office’s response to the joint Parliamentary call for evidence, from the Climate Action Committee and the Economy, Tourism and Energy Committee, on hyperscale data centres, a copy of which is sent with this letter.

I would therefore seek assurances that the Scottish Government will take a children’s rights-based approach to developing the guidance including by committing to conducting a Children’s Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment (CRWIA) and confirming how the views and voices of children and young people will inform your decision-making.

The approach taken to the guidance, and to datacentres more broadly will impact the Scottish Government’s ability to deliver on its statutory climate change targets as set out in the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009. I have therefore copied in your colleague Gillian Martin MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action and Rural Affairs.   

CRWIA

The Children’s Scheme published under s14 of the UNCRC (Scotland) Act 2024 provides that Ministers are required to prepare and publish a CRWIA for decisions of a strategic nature relating to children’s rights and wellbeing.

It is my view that the preparation and publication of data centres guidance is a clear example of a decision of a strategic nature. It is not an operational or routine matter and therefore a CRWIA must be undertaken.

I suggest that there should not only be a CRWIA on the overall guidance but on individual applications where the Scottish Ministers are the decision maker – such as the application at Redheughs, Edinburgh. Ministers have been clear these decisions are being called in for strategic oversight to be in place, recognising the collective and cumulative, as well as individual, impacts of large data centre developments.

Children and Young People’s Participation

I was disappointed to learn that the Scottish Government does not intend to carry out a public consultation to inform the content of the data centre guidance, instead relying on a targeted consultation with key stakeholders. I am concerned that this approach will not properly or meaningfully reflect the Government’s obligations to include the voices and views of children and young people in decision making.

Children and young people should be properly involved in decision-making processes surrounding these issues. This should be meaningful, effective and not tokenistic. Children and young people are clear that it is their future environment and want to be involved in protecting it.

The Scottish Government’s Public Engagement Strategy in respect of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 highlights the importance of this and states;

“Engagement must respect the rights of CYP and actively work to support climate literacy, critical thinking and participation, while enabling them to take action and have a voice in their communities. CYP bring creative ideas to climate engagement and their involvement in intergenerational and community engagement can add significant value to climate action delivery.”

The Scottish Government’s National Just Transition Planning Framework2021) states; “Youth voices are particularly important in this process given out intergenerational responsibility to deliver the best possible future for our young people; their voices must therefore be central to creating that net zero future.”

I would be grateful therefore for your response to the following:

Can the Scottish Government give an undertaking that a CRWIA will be carried out in relation to (i) the guidance and (ii) applications where the Scottish Ministers are the decision maker?

What is the Scottish Government doing to ensure that the meaningful participation of children and young people is a part of the development of this guidance on data centres, in line with the Public Engagement Strategy for the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 and the UNCRC requirements?

I look forward to hearing from you and am happy to meet to discuss these matters further.

Yours

Nicola Killean

Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland

Back to top