Response to Consultation on Updates to the Code of Practice for the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003

Response to Consultation on Updates to the Code of Practice for the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003

The Commissioner responded to Scottish Government’s consultation on updates to the Code of Practice for the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 which provide guidance on the use of restraint and seclusion. We raised the importance of clear guidance which complies with children’s rights and focuses on minimising the use of restraint.

Question 1a: Do you agree with the general principles and the purpose of restraint and seclusion, as described in the draft update?

While we support the General Principles set out, we would recommend they be framed through a concise set of core identifiable principles which clearly flow through the rest of the guidance, to reduce ambiguity and repetition. These would follow the principles discussed in the section, focused on preventing as far as possible and otherwise minimising restraint and seclusion, using the minimum necessary intervention for the shortest time, treating the person with dignity and respect for their rights and in a trauma informed manner, etc.

The section begins by setting out the requirements of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 (“the Act”), before going into additional human rights obligations incumbent on those operating under the Act. This drafting leaves ambiguity in how human rights obligations must be applied. In carrying out duties under the Act, public authorities must act compatibly with the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) under the provisions of the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), as well as compatibly with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) under the provisions of the UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024 (UNCRC Act). This includes interpreting the provisions of the Act in line with human rights obligations under the ECHR and UNCRC.[1] The guidance, in this section and elsewhere, should be clearer on the strength of these obligations in domestic law and set out more clearly the way in which duties to, for example, have regard to the welfare of the child sit alongside duties to have the child’s best interests as a primary consideration when reading the Act alongside human rights laws.

The way the provisions of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (UNCRPD) are set out, while welcome in noting wider human rights considerations, may also confuse the strength of human rights obligations under different treaties. It should be made clearer that the standards of the UNCRC and ECHR are binding in domestic law on public authorities, whereas UNCRPD rights are binding on the state in international law but not yet domestically enforceable.

We also recommend clearer and more consistent use of terminology around human rights throughout the guidance. The test for human rights compliant use of restraint and seclusion is that it must be necessary to prevent immediate harm to the patient or others, proportionate to that aim in that it must be the minimum use of force/isolation for the minimum amount of time necessary to achieve that goal, it must never be used for discipline or punishment, and it must be subject to review and access to remedy for patients where it is wrongly used.

The “Purpose of restraint” section appears to repeat and potentially confuse the general principles and definitions section, so we recommend it be incorporated as needed into the definitions section, which we have commented on in Question 3.

Question 2a: How clear, accurate and useful do you find the section on United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child?

At the outset to this section it must be made clear that children are protected fully by rights under the ECHR through the HRA but also enjoy additional protections under the UNCRC through the UNCRC Act. It may be helpful to set out the requirements of the ECHR in relation to restraint in the guidance alongside the additional protections of the UNCRC for children.

This section contains a significant error with regards to the obligations placed on public authorities by the UNCRC Act. As the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 (the Act) which the guidance is made under was passed by the Scottish Parliament following devolution, its provisions (which do not alter UK Acts) fall within the scope of the UNCRC Act. This means public authorities carrying out such duties under the Act must act compatibly with the rights of children set out under the UNCRC – not have regard to them, which is a weaker standard of compliance.[2]

The list of relevant UNCRC rights is missing some particularly relevant ones, including Article 2 which sets out that children should enjoy rights under the convention without discrimination. This includes discrimination on the basis of disability, which can be particularly important in mental health settings where young people’s mental illness, learning disability and/or autism/ADHD may amount to a disability, and may put them at risk of discriminatory treatment. The list also doesn’t note the importance of the right to be free from torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment under Article 37(1), which is a key element of Article 37 rights with regard to restraint. In general, the list of rights would benefit from additional context on the content of these rights and their relevance to the issue of restraint and seclusion. This may include drawing from the Committee’s General Comments, for example General Comment 8 which details the human rights standards for children under Articles 19 and 37 in relation to restraint.[3] Drawing from wider human rights standards would also be beneficial, for example explaining that the right to private life under Article 16 covers physical and psychological integrity.

As noted in Question 1, the section would benefit from consistent language around the human rights test for restraint. Some of the terms used in the section are of limited meaning in human rights terms, for example “person centred”. Including core human rights concepts such as the need to uphold the inherent dignity of the person more clearly sets out the requirements of the human rights framework.

As some areas of mental health law use 16 as a minimum age, the guidance should clarify here that the UNCRC applies to all children up to the age of 18.

The guidance notes the importance of advocacy services and complaints processes in this section, but these should be detailed in terms of requirements for children’s participation and their right to an appropriate remedy for any breach of their rights. It would also be helpful to highlight the importance of child friendly complaints procedures in enabling these rights.

Question 3a: Do you agree with our definitions of restraint and seclusion?

The Commissioner has raised the need for greater coordination on standards on and monitoring of the use of restraint on children and young people in different contexts across Scotland, including education, care and health settings.[4] This coordination is likely to be challenging where legislation and guidance across sectors differs significantly on the issue.

The Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Act 2026 in Section 1 defines restraint and seclusion quite differently to the definitions set out in this guidance. While we understand that the nature of restraint in mental health settings may be different, in part due to the treatment being provided there, the clinical setting and the complexity of caring for young people with significant mental illness, definitions across sectors should be consistent so far as possible, and share sufficient similarities to ensure national monitoring of restraint can be carried out in line with the recommendations of the Committee[5] and that human rights protections are upheld to the same degree in all settings where children are at risk of being subject to restraint or seclusion.

There are also differences in the overarching definition of restraint in the guidance from that set out by the Mental Welfare Commission in its 2021 Good Practice Guidance, which states that “Restraint is defined in relation to the degree of control, consent and intended purpose of the intervention”.[6] It would be helpful for the Consultation to detail why this decision was made. Any definition set out must capture all types of behaviour which amount to restraint, and this focus on restriction and purpose is important to this. We would recommend this be included in the guidance.

There are some aspects of the more detailed definitions of physical, mechanical or medication restraint which appear to undermine the safeguards set out elsewhere in the guidance with regards to the purpose of restraint and its limits and may undermine efforts to prevent and minimise the use of restraint on young people. The routine use of physical restraint ‘to enable necessary care or treatment’ where this cannot be justified as necessary due to a risk of harm may be in breach of human rights standards. Similarly, use of mechanical restraint in order to ‘manage behaviour’ may be at odds with requirements that it be used only to prevent harm. The section on medication does not properly distinguish between treatment focused medication where a patient is deemed to lack legal capacity and this has been properly authorised, versus medication specifically administered to treat or sedate a patient in direct response to a risk of harm.

It may be that the definitions are intended to capture all possible uses of restraint and then under the lawful limits section make clear what types are allowed. However this section appears to create uncertainty about what the guidance expects of practitioners and should be amended.

The seclusion definition reflects the definition used by the Mental Welfare Commission in its 2019 Good Practice Guidance, which is based on that used by the National Preventive mechanism. We support the use of this definition, but for clarity for users of the guidance we would recommend more explanation as to why the other situations listed do not amount to this, for example the autonomy of a patient choosing to be alone, or the difference between separation from some wards and isolation from all other individuals.

Question 4a: Do you agree with our guidance on the lawful limits of restraint and seclusion?

We are again concerned that the lawful limits on restraint and seclusion section appears to treat ECHR and UNCRC obligations as existing separately, when both apply to children and young people.

There is for example particular relevance to children and young people of existing standards around Article 3 ECHR. Restraint is more likely to reach the level of severity required to amount to inhuman or degrading treatment and therefore breach children’s Article 3 rights when carried out against children and young people, due to their age and potential vulnerability.[7]

Unlike the UNCRC section, the lawful limits section does not set out all the relevant rights under the ECHR and focuses entirely on Articles 3 and 5. While particularly relevant, the guidance should be clear that restraint and seclusion may also engage Articles 2, 8 and 14, for example, due to their possible use where there is risk to life, their impact on bodily integrity and their possible discriminatory application.[8]

The section should provide more detail on how assessments of whether something is necessary or proportionate can be made in line with human rights laws. For example, consideration must be made of other options in order for a form of restraint to be the minimum necessary. Similarly, Article 3 requires continuous review of the measure through its use to meet the standard of necessity.[9] This is similar with regard to seclusion and the risk of deprivation of liberty, where more detail would be helpful on how the degree and duration of seclusion can impact whether it amounts to a breach of Article 5.[10]

There are several references to Health Boards developing their own guidance on the lawful limits under the ECHR and keeping abreast of changes in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights in relation to Articles 3 and 5. Scottish Government should be providing in its own guidance a full and clear explanation of all the safeguards required by domestic human rights law, and should keep the guidance under review should updates be needed as case law develops. It is the responsibility of the Government to provide suitably clear and detailed statutory guidance on this issue as per its human rights obligations, and leaving this to health boards is likely to lead to inconsistency. Given the Scottish Government’s stated plans to reduce the number of regional Health Boards in Scotland, it appears particularly illogical not to provide clarity and consistency through national level guidance on such an important issue for children’s rights.

Question 5a: Do you agree with our recommendations around future care planning?

This section lacks reference to children and young people or the UNCRC, and creates an unhelpful separation in how the guidance can be understood and applied.

While some further information is given in the following section, this part of the guidance should set out the requirements that practitioners place the best interests of the child as a primary consideration, and that children’s views must be gathered in a way that is accessible to them, age appropriate, and enables their views to be meaningfully considered. It should also refer to the role of advocacy in supporting children in these processes.

Question 6a: Do you agree with our guidance for using restraint and seclusion with children and young people?

As noted in Questions 2 and 4, children and young people’s rights are protected by both the HRA and the UNCRC Act, and this should be reflected clearly in the guidance. We otherwise welcome the emphasis on the distinct position of children in terms of rights protections, the potentially serious impact of these practices on the wellbeing of young people already in distress, and the need for particularly high protection with regards to restraint and seclusion.

Paragraph 3 seeks to explain when restraint might be used as a last resort with children. We support the intention to provide greater clarity with regards to necessity of use, but while consideration of all alternative options is necessary, it may be misleading to suggest every other alternative measure needs to have been tried for restraint to be lawful.

The emphasis on assessing the child’s best interests and example considerations for this is welcome, but this obligation also requires practitioners to assess the best interests of other children either at risk of harm or witnessing restraint.

Although this is referenced to some extent, it may be helpful to clarify in this section that restraint can never be used as a form of discipline or punishment or in a way that degrades or causes humiliation, under Articles 3 ECHR and 37 UNCRC.

The debrief described should include the opportunity to involve family or advocacy support and must include information on how a child can complain if they feel it shouldn’t have happened or if it went too far. Children are in a uniquely vulnerable position in terms of their power and voice in these types of setting, meaning extra care needs to be taken to ensure their concerns can be heard by those beyond the team involved in restraint and examined independently when needed.

Question 7a: Do you agree with our guidance for using restraint and seclusion with autistic people and people with learning disabilities?

We support the acknowledgement in this section of the potential for more complex behavioural and distress presentation in autistic people and people with learning disabilities putting them at higher risk of restraint. It is also important to note the especially harmful impact restraint and seclusion can have in this group of young people. Autistic children and young people or those with learning disabilities are more likely to be subject to restraint and seclusion across a range of settings, and so the clarity of guidance and strength of protections in this area are particularly important, and we welcome the emphasis placed on these risks.

The section would benefit from additional emphasis on non-discrimination in the duties on practitioners to uphold human rights for these children and young people. The UNCRPD Committee has called on the UK to “adopt appropriate measures to eradicate the use of restraint for reasons related to disability […], as well as practices of segregation and isolation that may amount to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment”.[11] The guidance should emphasise the need to ensure restraint is not being used in a discriminatory way due to a child’s disability. Where children’s ability to communicate their needs is impacted by autism or a learning disability, there is a higher risk of mistreatment, and practitioners must have a detailed understanding of their obligations with relation to non-discrimination and the rights of disabled young people and the way this may impact assessments of necessity and proportionality.

Question 8a: Do you agree with our recommendations for using restraint and seclusion in the context of nasogastric tube feeding?

Media reporting in 2025 regarding mistreatment and restraint of young people at Skye house, many of whom were receiving treatment for eating disorders, highlighted an alarming failure in upholding the rights of some of Scotland’s most vulnerable young people. This consultation is one of the commitments made by government in order to prevent legal action by the Commissioner on this issue. More widely the Commissioner is aware of concerns around the treatment of children and young people with eating disorders in mental health settings and whether their rights are being upheld by those caring for them. Eating disorders are disproportionately experienced by girls and young women, and there is a risk that discriminatory treatment both on the basis of disability/diagnosis as well as sex can impact treatment in this area. Similar to Question 7, the guidance should highlight the risk of this and how it can be avoided.

Nasogastric tube feeding can be particularly traumatic for those receiving it, especially when carried out under restraint, and it is important practitioners are able to make appropriate, human rights compliant assessments of when the risk of serious harm to or death of the child or young person requires this to be carried out. Emphasis in this section of the guidance should once again be placed on the goal of minimising use of restraint in these scenarios, which may become routine in these contexts, potentially becoming disproportionate and unnecessary.

It is useful that the guidance notes the thresholds that must be met here, and the elements which would contribute to a proportionality assessment. However, in our view, to implement this guidance effectively practitioners would need more detail on how to make these assessments as to whether restraint is being used as a last resort – such as whether it may be more possible to attempt NGT feeding with more time and support. More guidance on the importance of respecting a child and young person’s dignity when carrying out restraint in these circumstances would also be welcome. While reference is made to the Mental Welfare Commission’s good practice guidance, it would be better to include some of this more detailed guidance at a statutory level to ensure national guidance is clear and effective.

Question 9a: Do you agree with our recommendations for monitoring and recording the use of restraint and seclusion?

The Committee has recommended Governments in the UK “regularly collect, analyse and publish disaggregated data on the use of stop-and-search checks, harmful devices, seclusion, restraint, solitary confinement and isolation on children”.[12] It specifically highlighted the need to improve data collection relating to violence against children, mental health, and children with disabilities, and the need for data to be disaggregated by age, sex, disability, geographical location, ethnic origin, nationality and socioeconomic background. The UNCRPD Committee has also recommended the UK “set up strategies, in collaboration with monitoring authorities and national human rights institutions, in order to identify and prevent the use of restraint for children and young persons with disabilities”.[13] The Scottish Government therefore has obligations under the UNCRC as well as its wider international obligations under UNCRPD to collect, publish and analyse data gathered by health boards in line with the guidance.

In order to track the use of restraint and seclusion and identify when there may be evidence of its overuse or a failure in standards to use it only as a last resort, data must be recorded consistently across Health Boards as well as at the national level, and as far as possible while maintaining confidentiality, this data should be published to enable accountability. We have previously highlighted to the Scottish Parliament the need to ensure proper national level data collection with regard to restraint in schools. We would recommend the Scottish Government ensure a coordinated approach to gathering and publishing relevant data on restraint and seclusion in all relevant settings across Scotland. We welcome the commitment to ensure the Mental Welfare Commission is appropriately resourced to carry out this monitoring role and look forward to it being implemented as quickly as possible.

Question 10a: Do you agree with our recommendations for staff planning, training and welfare?

As noted in response to Question 4, we don’t think it’s appropriate for detailed guidance on restraint to be left to individual health boards, particularly where uncertainty remains about how these will sit together following proposed public sector reform.

We otherwise agree with the parameters set out for training focus and would defer to organisations involved in practice to comment further. Consideration should be given as to whether certification is required for consistency in training.   

The section acknowledges that a failure to properly resource mental health care can mean restraint and seclusion are more likely to be used when not a last resort, as a result of staffing pressures. We would reiterate that Scottish Government must properly fund children and young people’s mental health care at a national level to enable proper resourcing and ensure the guarantee not only of their right to health, but that their wider human rights are protected including with regards to restraint and seclusion.

Question 11a: Are there any other specific groups or clinical contexts that would need specific guidance, in relation to the use of restraint and seclusion? If so, please tell us more.

See Question 3 response on coordination of guidance and monitoring of restraint and seclusion.

Question 12a: Would you be in favour of the development of further guidance that sets out the requirements for the use of restraint and seclusion in mental health settings in Scotland in greater detail?

The Commissioner welcomes the creation of statutory guidance on the use of restraint and seclusion in mental healthcare settings, in line with the commitments made to our office by the Scottish Government and its obligations under human rights laws. However, the consultation does not clearly explain what further guidance is planned, or what the difference in scope and purpose of additional guidance will be. As a general point, we would prefer there to be one authoritative source of statutory guidance on this issue.

The UN Committee on the Rights of the Child (the Committee) had in its 2023 Concluding Observations to the UK called for Governments to “develop statutory guidance on the use of restraint on children to ensure that it is used only as a measure of last resort and exclusively to prevent harm to the child or others and monitor its implementation”.[14] The Committee in its General Comment 13 on the right of the child to be free from all forms of violence, which can include isolation, humiliating or degrading treatment as well as failure to prevent or treat eating disorders and self harm, sets out that a failure to uphold this Article 19 right includes “failure to adopt or revise legislation and other provisions, inadequate implementation of laws and other regulations and insufficient provision of material, technical and human resources and capacities to identify, prevent and react to violence against children”.[15] General Comment 8 on the right of children to protection from corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading forms of punishment states “Detailed guidance and training is also required, both to minimize the necessity to use restraint and to ensure that any methods used are safe and proportionate”.[16] The Scottish Government’s compliance with its obligations under the UNCRC are therefore dependent on effective statutory guidance being put forward.

More detailed guidance for practitioners, including more detailed examples of what types of actions may amount to restraint or seclusion, what factors to consider and how to make decisions on necessity in different circumstances, is needed to make sure these practices are used only when necessary and as a last resort in line with the Committee’s recommendation. While patient monitoring and planning may mean it is possible to assess options as situations develop, in mental health and other contexts there is a likelihood of restraint being used at times where decisions have to be made very quickly in response to rapid escalation or rapidly changing circumstances. This makes detailed guidance, training and monitoring necessary to support staff in upholding children’s rights. We would recommend the Government consult with practitioners and bodies including the Mental Welfare Commission to create effective practical guidance at a national level.

Question 13a: Do you have any other comments on the proposed changes to the Code of Practice Volume 1?

Overall, we recommend the code be reviewed for coherence, consistency and to prevent repetition, as in its current form it may not be easy for users to follow. At times the structure of the code creates repetitive framing but using slightly different terminology, which is likely to create confusion. In one section the term restrictive interventions is used instead of restraint and seclusion, we would recommend consistency of these terms throughout. Likewise different framings are used to describe the human rights test in a way that is unhelpful.

The separation of human rights requirements under the HRA from those under the UNCRC Act risks creating the impression that one is for adults and one is for children. Instead, children receive protection under both pieces of legislation, and children would benefit from practitioners understanding and applying domestic human rights frameworks as a coherent set of rules instead of two separate considerations where both apply.

Question 15b: Do you have any comments or suggestions to improve the clarity, accuracy or usefulness of the new Chapter 17?

We have similar concerns to those set out in Question 2 that UNCRC Act obligations in this section are referred to as requiring to have regards to rights, when they should be to act compatibly with rights.

We would suggest that reference be made in this section to the possibility that a child or young person may seek to rely on the UNCRC requirements in any Tribunal application, and that if so, the Tribunal will be required to comply with The Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland (Practice and Procedure) (No. 2) Amendment Rules 2026.

For further information, please contact Emma Hunter, Policy Officer at emma.hunter@cypcs.org.uk


[1] Section 3 Human Rights Act and s24 UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act

[2] Section 6(1) UNCRC Act

[3] Authoritative interpretive sources on the Convention in line with Section 4(2)(c) UNCRC Act.

[4] See CYPCS, Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill – Stage 1 evidence to the Education, Children and Young People Committee, July 2025

[5] UNCRC Concluding observations on the combined sixth and seventh periodic reports of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (2023), CRC/C/GBR/CO/6-7, para 12(c)

[6] Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland, Rights, risks and limits to freedom – Good Practice Guide, March 2021, para 1.1

[7] Kalashnikov v Russia (2003) 36 EHRR 34 para 95

[8] See Equality and Human Rights Commission, Human rights framework for restraint, March 2019.

[9] Lavorgna v. Italy, [2024] ECHR 843, para 123

[10] See Stanev v. Bulgaria [2012] ECHR 46 2012, para 115 and A Reference by the Attorney General for Northern Ireland of a devolution issue under paragraph 34 of Schedule 10 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 [2026] UKSC 16 para 118

[11] UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Concluding observations on the initial report of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, (2017), CRPD/C/GBR/CO/1*, Para 37(a)

[12] UNCRC Concluding observations on the combined sixth and seventh periodic reports of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (2023), CRC/C/GBR/CO/6-7, para 12(c)

[13] UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Concluding observations on the initial report of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, (2017), CRPD/C/GBR/CO/1*, Para 37(b)

[14] UNCRC Concluding observations on the combined sixth and seventh periodic reports of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland (2023), CRC/C/GBR/CO/6-7, para 30(b)

[15] UNCRC General Comment 13 (2011), The right of the child to freedom from all forms of violence, CRC/C/GC/13, para 32

[16] UNCRC General Comment 8 (2006) The right of the child to protection from corporal punishment and other cruel or degrading forms of punishment (arts. 19; 28, para. 2; and 37, inter alia), para 15


docx Download

Size: 83.80 KB

Download 262911 MH CoP response Final docx
Back to top