Response to the ‘Use of Stop and Search – Revised Code of Practice’ consultation

Response to the ‘Use of Stop and Search – Revised Code of Practice’ consultation

May 2026

Established by the Commissioner for Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2003, the Commissioner is responsible for promoting and safeguarding the rights of all children and young people in Scotland, giving particular attention to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). The Commissioner has powers to review law, policy and practice and to take action to promote and protect rights. The Commissioner is fully independent of the Scottish Government.


  • Does the revised Code clearly set out the circumstances in which a search of a person may be carried out when the person is not in police custody?

No

  • Does the revised Code clearly set out the procedures to be followed in carrying out a search of a person who is not in police custody?

No

  • Please suggest any areas that could be made clearer or more detailed, or any other improvements that would support better understanding.

In the draft revised code it states;

‘5.2 The co-operation of the person to be searched must be sought in every case, even if they initially object to the search. The law allows constables to use reasonable force if necessary to conduct the search. This means the minimum amount of force necessary to accomplish the lawful objective of the search, for example the use of handcuffs to safeguard all those involved.’

The current code, alongside the revised code, on search applies to all individuals being searched with the addition of a section which only applies to children and young people. The above paragraph applies to all individuals, including children and young people, therefore there is no specific guidance on the use of force to conduct a search on a child or young person. We feel there should be specific guidance, or a link to other guidance, relating to when the use of force is appropriate and the differences in using this against children and young people who are inherently more vulnerable and at risk of injury.

International human rights law recognises the profound imbalance of power between children and the State, requiring higher standards of protection to account for children’s age and additional vulnerability compared to adults. For example, children may be at greater risk of harm from the use of force due to their size or stage of development, while specific groups of children may have additional vulnerabilities that place them more at risk

The use of force to search a child or young person should only be used in extreme circumstances and where there is an immediate risk of harm. When force is used against children and young people, the level of force used should be proportionate and at all times the minimum amount of force necessary should be used.

As articulated in the recent in-depth report on strip searches by the Children’s Commissioner for England,  it is unlikely such a threshold (immediate risk of harm) will be met in the majority of cases involving the possession of drugs.[1]

In the draft revised code it states;

‘5.10 Constables must ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the person understands why they are to be searched and what the search will involve. If the person to be searched does not appear to understand what is being said, the constable must take reasonable steps to bring information regarding the person’s rights and any relevant provisions of this Code to their attention.’

We would welcome guidance regarding the use of interpreters for those who do not speak English as a first language. If such a child or young person was to be searched then they may require this to properly understand the procedure.


  • Does the revised Code provide clear guidance to ensure everyone is treated fairly and respectfully during a search?

No

  • Please provide any suggestions where the Code could be strengthened or provide stronger protection for individual or group rights?

There is a lack of reference to the UNCRC throughout the Code, the Code should be framed in a way which promotes children’s rights under the UNCRC. where there is reference to the UNCRC, the information is incorrect.


  • Does the revised Code provide clear guidance on how strip searches and intimate searches should be conducted?

No

  • Please provide any suggestions for how the guidance on strip or intimate searches could be improved strengthened.

In the draft revised code it states

5.5 ‘In the case of a small article which can readily be concealed, such as a drug, and which might be concealed anywhere on the person, a more extensive search may be necessary including a strip search or intimate search.’

The latest concluding observations of the UK and Northern Ireland from the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child urged that legislative steps are taken to ‘explicitly prohibit, without exception’ the use of ‘strip searches on children’[2]. We highlight this to show how serious an interference with the rights of children that a strip or intimate search is.

We do see there being some limited circumstances where this type of search could be appropriate where there is an immediate risk of significant harm. Our view aligns with the Children’s Commissioner for England –

‘The Children’s Commissioner believes that children should only be strip searched in extremely rare circumstances, where there is an immediate risk of significant harm; it is unlikely that this will be the case in the majority of cases where the search is for the suspicion of carrying drugs.’[3]

Within the revised code, there is limited guidance on the particular sensitivities which exist when it comes to conducting intimate or strip searches on children and young people, compared to adults. This is a serious interference with children’s rights under the UNCRC. We think it should be clearer that this should only be used as a last resort in extreme circumstances for children and young people. When it is absolutely necessary, then the protections afforded to children and young people should be much stronger.

The guidance states that when conducting a strip search the constable should ‘try’ to have a responsible adult present – this does not seem to offer sufficient protection. We think the provisions should be strengthened with regard to children and young people.

Specific consideration of the circumstances of when it is appropriate to carry out an intimate or strip search on a child or young person – this should be different to the circumstances when it is done for an adult. We do not believe that the suspicion of possession of drugs will automatically meet the criteria for carrying out a strip or intimate search on a child or young person.

More detail on the protections which should be afforded to children and young people should be given to support officers in their role and protect children’s rights.


  • Does the revised Code provide clear guidance on establishing the sex of a person for the purposes of a search?

No.

  • Please provide further comments if you think the Code could be strengthened to support consistent and respectful practice.

In relation to guidance on ‘establishing sex’, requests about a child or young person’s birth sex engage their privacy rights under Article 8 ECHR, as well as Article 16 UNCRC alongside their right to be treated with dignity under Article 19. Under both the Human Rights Act and the UNCRC (Scotland) Act, any interference with children’s right to privacy must not be arbitrary and must meet the strict test of being necessary to achieve a specific, legitimate aim and being proportionate to that aim.

The provisions on ‘establishing sex’ are outlined throughout 8.28 and 8.33 of the draft guidance. At no point in these proposed provisions is it mentioned that these may affect children and young people differently from adults– nor is their guidance on how a situation of ‘determining sex’ might require a different approach or considerations or protections if involving a child or young person.

For example, the guidance suggests that a ‘constable can refer to official documentation or identity documents’, it is more unlikely that a child or young person will have this documentation on their person. There is no provision made for the appropriateness or not of involvement of a ‘responsible adult’, carer or parent.

The guidance suggests that a search (being an intimate or strip search) can proceed on the basis of the officers ‘honest and reasonable’ belief of the persons ‘biological’ sex. It should be recognised that the implications of this for a child, especially one whose gender identity is different from their birth sex, could potentially result in harm due to intrusive questioning from adults or assumptions about their identity.

The guidance does not contain any explicit information regarding the situation of intersex or non-binary children and young people. Are police officers being sufficiently supported in their role if these situations are not addressed in the guidance?

This revised Code of Practice will need to take into account expected EHRC guidance for public services, which is not yet available.


  • Does the revised Code clearly explain how children and young people should be treated when being stopped and searched by police?

No

  • Please provide further comments if you think the Code could be strengthened to ensure children and young people are safeguarded and treated fairly and respectfully.

The revised Code it states;

The Scottish Ministers are required to comply with the UNCRC in exercising their relevant function under section 74 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2016 of updating the Stop and Search Code of Practice. Police constables in Scotland must comply with the UNCRC when exercising search functions conferred by Acts of Scottish Parliament or common law – but they do not have to comply with the UNCRC when exercising search functions conferred by Acts of the UK Parliament. While Scottish Ministers must comply with the UNCRC when updating the Code, police constables acting under that Code will only have to comply with the UNCRC when exercising search functions conferred by an Act of the Scottish Parliament or common law.

We disagree with the wording of the above section., The UNCRC was ratified by the UK Government in 1991, since then public bodies have had a duty to comply with it. The 2025 Act brought in means of enforcement to realise these rights directly but this does not mean that officers should not be upholding the rights of children in everything they do.

We welcome the changes in the revised code at 7.14 and 7.15 which add in guidance on the impact of ‘adultification’ and welcome the focus on the impact of search on children and young people who are also asylum seekers and ethnic minorities.

We also welcome the provision in the revised code at 7.11 which gives further clarity regarding children and young people in need of learning support.

We are concerned that a number of provisions in the outstanding code have been removed from the revised code and note several protections which previously existed have been removed. We have not seen explanation as to why these have been removed and we are concerned this may weaken the protections afforded to children and young people.

The provisions contained in the revised Code of Practice currently remove the previous requirement that for a child or young person under the age of 18 be searched by a person of the same sex.

In the current guidance the requirement at 7.20 states;

‘Any search of a child or a young person should be carried out by a person of the same sex’.

We were concerned that it was initially proposed that this provision be removed, and contacted Scottish Government too seek an explanation for this proposal. We have been reassured by the policy team working on the Code that the intention is not to remove this provision and it will be reinstated.

We would otherwise be concerned that this would weaken children’s rights under the UNCRC – Article 16 provides for the right to privacy and Article 19 states that children have the right to be treated with dignity.

The following sections were in the current code but not the revised code:

‘7.5 Constables should ensure that the principles of fairness, integrity and respect apply equally to children and young people, as they do to adults.’

This provision from the current guidance has been removed in the new draft guidance, no explanation has been given.

‘7.12 Where it appears to a constable that a child/young person lacks the capacity to understand why a search may be necessary, or what a search may entail, then the presumption is that the search should not proceed. Consideration should then be made of how best to safeguard that child or young person, where it is believed that child or young person continues to be at risk of harm.’

This provision has been removed from the current guidance and is not in the updated version. We feel that this is an important protection for children with disabilities or neurodivergence.

‘7.16 Even where there is no history of abuse, children and young people have reported that being searched by someone who is a stranger to them is both uncomfortable and intrusive.’

This section has been removed. This section offered a level of protection which no longer appears in the updated guidance. Keeping this section would be in line with a trauma informed approach.

‘7.17 Where a child or young person is becoming distressed during a search, consideration should be given to discontinuing the search or pausing it until a responsible adult can be present (where this is practicable and the child or young person wishes this to happen).’

This section has been removed from the new guidance, this section previously offered a protection and was in line with a trauma informed approach.

‘7.18 For the purposes of this Code, a “responsible adult” is defined as someone over the age of 18, with responsibility for the child or young person. This might include, for example, a parent or carer, an older sibling or a key worker. Their role is to support the child or young person and help them understand what is happening. Constables should note that a „responsible adult‟ is distinct from an „appropriate adult‟, a term which has its own meaning.’

This section has been removed; there is now no definition of what a ‘responsible’ adult is for the purposes of the guidance. This is concerning as this could for example include another police officer or civilian member of the police?

‘7.20 Any search of a child or a young person should be carried out by a person of the same sex (see Annex B). All searches should respect the dignity and privacy of the child or young person.’

This section has been removed – we have outlined more detail on this above.

‘7.21 A constable should explain at each stage of a search of a child or young person what they are doing and why. Where a child requests a brief pause in the search (for example, to compose themselves) then this should be accommodated, where practicable. The search should be completed as swiftly as possible.’

This section has been removed. Keeping this section would be in line with a trauma informed approach.

‘7.23 Where a search takes place and no item is found and the child or young person has provided their name, address and date of birth, a constable should clearly explain how the information will be stored, the length of time it will be kept and the purposes for which it may be used.

7.24 Following completion of a search, a child or a young person should be supplied with a receipt, which should include age appropriate information about stop and search, and details of how to make a complaint if the child or young person feels that they have been treated unfairly.’

These sections have been removed and are now covered earlier in the guidance under sections regarding providing receipts for searches. There is now no differentiation as to the receipts given to adults and to children and young people which existed in the previous guidance. There is also no reference to the need to provide ‘age-appropriate information’.

While we would expect that after incorporation bodies will work in this way – losing the explicit guidance on age-appropriate information is a backward step. This explicit provision tells police officers how to work in a UNCRC compliant way.

‘7.25 Constables should be aware that children and young people can find it difficult to access complaints processes, which are often designed by adults for adults. Where a complaint is received by the Police from or on behalf of a child or young person, consideration should be given to how best to respond in an age appropriate, timely and child-centred manner.’

This has been removed and the new guidance does not contain information on child friendly complaints.

‘7.33 Children and young people may have additional support needs beyond those outlined in this chapter. It therefore important that constables also familiarise themselves with the content of Chapter 8 and consider how this may apply to children and young people.’

This section has been removed from the proposed  guidance. We feel that this provides an important link to the information which is contained within the sections on ‘vulnerable people’ highlighting the overlap between children who may have additional vulnerabilities outlined there (Part 6 in the new guidance).

Consideration should be given to reinstating some of the provisions from the previous guidance which have been removed.

In addition to this we would like to see the provision of child friendly materials and guidance, and a child friendly complaints system.

We note that at the stage of publication of the revised code, a CRIA was not available, we understand that this will be prepared to go alongside the finalised version – if a CRIA had been available at this stage then it might have assisted in our understanding of why certain sections had been removed and what the mitigations are.


  • Does the revised Code provide sufficient guidance on how police should identify and interact with people who may be vulnerable or need extra support?

No

  • Please provide further comments if you think the revised Code could include additional measures or safeguards to ensure vulnerable people are adequately protected during a stop and search.

It should be made explicitly clear that the provisions on vulnerable people apply equally to children and young people. As stated above, in the current guidance 7.33 provided a link between these two sections and a similar provision could be contained within the proposed guidance.


  • Does the revised Code clearly set out the right of someone to receive a copy of the information and record kept in relation to a search of a person who is not in police custody?

No

  • Does the revised Code clearly set out the right of someone to receive a copy of the information and record kept in relation to a search of a person who is not in police custody?

No

  • Please provide further comments if there are improvements you would like to see in how stop and search data is collected, monitored or reported.

As we have highlighted above, under the current guidance there are specific sections outlining the considerations for children and young people and the need to provide age-appropriate information – these have been removed and the provisions for adults and for children/ young people are all the same. Consideration should be given to how this information should be tailored to be appropriate for children and young people.


Is there anything in the revised Code that should be added, changed or removed?

Yes


[1] Strip search of children in England and Wales | Children’s Commissioner for England

[2] https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/4013807?ln=en

[3] Strip search of children in England and Wales | Children’s Commissioner for England

Back to top