What needs to change?

It’s essential that children and young people are at the heart of our work and we spend time listening to children and young people to find out what’s important to them. We need to know what matters to children so we can work on the issues they care about. Mental health is a topic that children consistently raise with us and feel strongly about it. This Children’s Mental Health Week, we’re sharing what young people have told us about mental health over the last year or so, we will explain the rights issues around mental health, and what we want to see changing…
What children have told us:
“Sometimes people bottle it up then explode.”
“[Good mental health means] you won’t feel overwhelmed, you’ll feel lighter.”
“[Poor mental health] can affect your studies, relationships, everything. It can really harm your mind and body.”
“There’s a lot of support in school, but it’s so unnerving to ask for help.”
“You have to talk to someone about it. It won’t help hiding it away.”
Why are we working on mental health?
Because thousands of children and young people have told us to.
When we asked what issues mattered to them for our Strategic Plan in 2020, they were clear that mental health should be a priority for us. Again, for our new Strategic Plan in 2024, they said the same thing. Some said that things had even got worse for mental health in the past few years because of the coronavirus pandemic.
Rights in the UNCRC
The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC) says that children have the right to the best possible health – and that includes mental health. That doesn’t mean that children will never be affected by a mental health condition, like anxiety or depression, but it means that if they do, they should have access to support and treatment when they need it, and in a way that suits them.
Impact of pandemic and cost-of-living crisis
Mental health care was a human rights issue before the coronavirus pandemic, but the disruption to services and the impact of school closures and increased stress and anxiety made things worse. The cost-of-living crisis has also affected children’s mental health. Around one in four children live in poverty in Scotland which can impact physical and mental health, and impact other rights like education.
What have we called for?
Children and young people have been telling us they need mental health support before they reach crisis point. We want:
- community-based mental health services that are easy for children to access before they are in a crisis – putting the right people where children can find them, like youth clubs and other informal community spaces,
- more health visitors, more school nurses, more counsellors in schools and in communities,
- services to harness support from the third sector (like charities and community groups) and from other health professionals, like occupational therapists and speech and language therapists,
- children to be able to access care that is appropriate to their age, and when they need specialist support, they should not be sent to adult medical wards, which risks breaching their rights, and
- the Scottish Government to use funding to invest in more mental health services to support children and young people.
Young Advisors’ Investigation

Young people have been closely involved in our shaping our work on mental health. Our Young Advisors used the Commissioner’s powers to investigate the provision of counsellors in secondary schools, and made lots of recommendations based on what they found out. The investigation – Mental Health: Counselling in Schools – was the first time anywhere in the world that young people had used a children’s commissioner’s legal powers of investigation.
After requesting and analysing data from local authorities, the Young Advisors’ recommendations included that:
- all children should have a right of access to counselling at school,
- local authorities should ensure that counselling is available outside school hours, during school holidays and outside school premises, on request,
- the Scottish Government should expand school counselling provision to all primary and special schools in Scotland, and
- all local authorities should have clear waiting times for children who want to access services, and information should be child-friendly.
The Young Advisors raised awareness of the investigation when it was launched. Grace shared what the group found out about mental health counselling on BBC Radio Five Live. She said: “We discovered that mental health counselling in schools was something that was kept quiet, it wasn’t being used to its full extent and it wasn’t being used before children were hitting crisis point.
“It was kept behind a closed door in schools – unless a teacher or someone was close to a school counsellor you wouldn’t be made aware of it.”
Young Advisor Lewis talked about the group’s findings that not enough children and young people knew there were services even available to them. He said: “[Support] needs to be more open and more accessible. It needs to be accessed whenever and wherever you need it.”
The office continues to urge the Scottish Government and COSLA to implement as many of the investigation recommendations as possible.
Listen to an audio clip of the national radio programme the Young Advisors took part in.
Our latest work
When children and young people are asked their views, they often find it difficult to know if the Government and people who run services are listening to them. They may have made recommendations on how to improve mental health services, but can’t see what has happened next. We are doing some new research to try to track what happens after those recommendations have been made. Is there evidence that things changed? If not, can we see what happened? We’ll be turning this into a report to share what we find in Spring 2025.